Artistic Dignity

Throughout my life I have been surrounded by art, and there is no greater human value for me than aesthetic beauty. It is precisely for this reason that one must clearly define the very concept of beauty and aesthetics… especially in a modern world overflowing with the most varied forms of so-called art, each of which lays claim to some profound aesthetic depth or conceptual significance.

Like all my teachers and friends in the realm of creativity, for a long time I too was under the influence of artistic authorities. By this I mean that many authors are considered talented solely because they are famous. Conversely, many paintings are declared great a priori simply because they were created by a renowned artist. In the end, it becomes a closed, self-reinforcing circle: an artist is deemed a genius because he is famous, and he is famous precisely because he is considered a genius. And if he is a genius, then by definition he cannot create a bad painting. Should the work fail to please you, the fault lies not with the painting, but with your own imperfect perception as a viewer. No critic will ever declare that a piece is bad. They will merely suggest that you have not yet risen to the level required to understand it. This is how the concept of artistic snobbery was invented: to shame others by declaring them aesthetically and intellectually underdeveloped, while pointing triumphantly at works that possess neither true aesthetic beauty nor any genuine intellectual depth.

I am certain you have often observed this same mentality in music, among film directors, and in all other spheres of art. There always emerges some proclaimed “genius”, and whose every work is immediately deemed worthy of your attention merely because it bears his name or because the piece has found its way into the catalogue of yet another authoritative gallery. Recall how many times you have endured bad music solely because it was popular. Or how often you have sat through certain films, straining to understand what was supposedly good about them, convincing yourself that perhaps you were the one who simply did not understand — for if millions of people found something of value in it, then surely there must be something truly worthwhile.

I confess that in my youth I too was exactly such a person. And to speak honestly, every young soul should… indeed, is obliged to… consume as much art as possible, both the sublime and the utter rubbish. For without this, one cannot truly come to know the world, expand one’s horizons, and forge one’s own refined sense of taste.

Now, with the wisdom of years, my creative tastes and aesthetic sense have fully matured. I can state with absolute certainty what I consider true and sublime art, worthy of the greatest poems of praise and admiration, and what I regard as not art at all, but mere garbage and vulgar pollution of our civilisation that deserves to be erased from the face of the earth.

Yes, I am a merciless critic. In the modern world of mass media, where billions of the most varied points of view and concepts fall upon us like an unrelenting deluge, and where every individual is convinced that he is a bold innovator or yet another genius endowed with a unique aesthetic taste, I believe it is essential to cut away the superfluous with ruthless and unrelenting precision by the blade of Occam’s razor.

To a certain extent, I consider myself a specialist in the art field. I received my artistic academy degree in Paris. I have visited a great number of the most renowned museums of the Old World, and there is perhaps no celebrated artist (whether historical or contemporary) whose works I have not seen with my own eyes. By the long-standing tradition of our family, every two years we travel to the Venice Art Biennale to behold the creations of the world’s foremost artists. For some time I was also engaged in the appraisal and restoration of art, and I can easily distinguish the quality of technical execution. Not to mention the ability to tell a forgery from an original at a glance.

At the same time, I lay no claim to universal truth. I speak solely of my own values and my own convictions. If someone derives pleasure from works that I do not appreciate, I shall never seek to forbid them their enjoyment… but let them keep it far away from me. Otherwise, they will receive the most severe and destructive criticism.

Here it is necessary to clearly define what art truly is, and what it most certainly is not.

The Oxford Encyclopedic Dictionary defines “art” as "the use of the imagination to express ideas or feelings". I agree with this definition, and it is precisely for this reason that the output of generative neural networks cannot be considered art by definition. A machine possesses neither ideas, nor feelings, nor imagination… only calculated imitation. These imitations may be astonishingly convincing, yet they are no different from claiming that a reflection in a mirror can be art. It cannot.

This brings us to a very fine line: where does art begin and mere imitation end, when so much of art itself is an imitation of reality? My answer is unequivocal and lies already within the very definition of the word: "…to express ideas or feelings". Without them, it ceases to be art and becomes mere imitation for the sake of imitation. It is also essential to understand that ideas and feelings are the ultimate goal in themselves. If these ideas and feelings serve merely as a catalyst to provoke the viewer into some subsequent action, then it is no longer art.

Any advertisement falls inside the dictionary definition of art, but it's not, for it stirs a sense of hunger in the viewer solely so that the person will purchase a product. The primary goal is money, rather than to awaken thoughts. Similarly, propaganda instils certain ideas in order to compel the individual toward specific actions. In such cases, ideas and feelings exist only in service of a vicious ulterior motive. No, the true art cannot serve as a stepping stone to something else. Art is an end in itself… a self-contained, complete form.

Undoubtedly, art may and should inspire. In this lies the very essence of sharing ideas and feelings. And of course, people may perform deeds under the influence of art. However, unlike advertising and propaganda, art must always leave the viewer a free space… the freedom to decide in which direction their imagination and inspiration will unfold. Thus, the absence of rigid mental boundaries is one of the most important hallmarks of true creativity. For I believe that genuine creation must expand all intellectual and emotional horizons, rather than confine them to a single narrow channel. Therefore, I classify any purposeful advertising or propaganda as not art.

If the appreciation of an art piece requires an entire collection, a particular viewpoint, special lighting, lecture or any other external aid or information, then it is also not art. Yes, an artwork may form part of a greater project or a vast collection, yet even then it must be whole on its own. For every small detail within a true work must possess its own meaning, its own inner logic, and the power to awaken feelings independently… even when removed from the context of the larger concept. Of course, any additional knowledge and context can enrich a work of art. However, the work itself must be whole and self-sufficient, capable of conveying its ideas and evoking feelings even if the viewer possesses none of that additional knowledge.

By the same logic, I do not consider sketches to be art either, for they are not the final work, but merely working material. This applies equally to patterns, technical drawings, film scripts, and all other preparatory forms. Though I confess that I personally derive great pleasure from reading and studying such behind-the-scenes materials… sometimes they reveal far more about a work than the finished piece itself. But one cannot judge a work of art only by its initial intention. One must always look at the final result. Otherwise, it is no different from judging any action solely by the desire behind it. Sketches and drafts may at times be flawless, yet their ultimate realisation can prove monstrous… and vice versa.

However, intention behind the art also carries an important indicator that cannot be entirely ignored. We exclude advertising and propaganda from the list precisely because of their original intent, even though many individual works may possess genuine artistic merit. If a work is created solely for the purpose of financial gain, I find it extremely difficult to perceive it as true art.

It is here that I enter into confrontation with a great many art historians and critics. Historically, the absolute majority of artworks were indeed created with the aim of earning money, and that is true. Yet one must consider the context. In the XXI century, every person has thousands of cheap ways to produce “art” on any topic, at any time and in any place. However in XIX century and earlier, matters stood quite differently. Even when an artist or composer received a commission, it was still a highly limited endeavour. The creator knew he was making a single, unique work, and therefore poured into it all his knowledge, skill, strength, emotion, and life experience. It was precisely after the advent of Impressionism (yes, it deserves my hate), when art began to scale and transform into a form of pop culture of its time, that paintings and painters began to degrade. I am not at all against a work of art generating profit. On the contrary, I support it. However, for a true artist, profit must never be the primary goal or intention.

Thus I regard the entire modern art market, where paintings are treated primarily as economic investments, with great disdain. I believe that the more expensive a work becomes in such markets, the less artistic and human value it actually possesses.

Continuing the theme of intention, I find no artistic value in works whose primary purpose is to insult or diminish someone… especially when the insult is directed at the viewer or listener himself. And believe me, I have seen a great many films, paintings, and particularly pieces of music that seemed to go out of their way to insult my intelligence.

True art can have only one fundamental intention: one of creation and elevation, never the opposite.

Yes, creativity may and indeed must raise the darkest and most oppressive themes, for it is the only space where one can speak openly about any subject. However, if an author merely describes degradation, destruction, and decay without offering any path toward improvement, I find little value in such work. I do not claim that every piece of art must be positive, joyful, or end on a note of happiness. On the contrary, I hold quite the opposite view. Yet if an author raises difficult and painful questions, he should at the very least attempt to provide his own answers… even if those answers are imperfect or doubtful. To criticise is easy; to criticise and propose is the mark of true depth.

And to conclude this section: good art must always be able to answer one fundamental question — has the world become better for the mere existence of this artwork?

It seems to me that this is one of the most important criteria of art. And what is more, when I ask myself this question, I realise with horror that even not every one of my own creations can boast that the world has become better because of its existence.

So if everything listed above is not art, then what shall we call it? I simply call it "content". It may be of high or low quality, but that does not change the fact that it remains content and nothing more. Here I shall present the hierarchical pyramid by which I perceive creative works. For me, they are divided into three levels. At the bottom stands Content. Above it stands Art. And at the very summit stands the greater form of creation, which I call Heritage.

— Content, as has already been described, is human creation whose purpose is to appear, fulfil its function, and disappear. A vivid example is the beautiful wrapper of a chocolate bar. The wrapper sells you the sweetness with its bright and tempting image, only to be torn and thrown away. The absolute majority of human creative output falls precisely into this category.

— Art itself. Works that meet all the criteria mentioned earlier: capable of impartially and selflessly inspiring and uplifting people, bestowing upon them ideas and emotions. Pure, authorial self-expression.

— Heritage. This is when the author creates not merely a good work of art, but understands that this is the very thing that will remain after him… forever. His epitaph. The work by which centuries later people will judge him — both as a person and as an artist. The work into which he pours all his mastery and all his knowledge. It is the highest form of art… art in which even the author himself forgives no imperfection. A true magnum opus is one that the creator makes first and foremost for himself alone… even if he knows that others may never understand or appreciate it. He continues to create it with burning obsession, because he simply cannot live in any other way

What, then, is the difference between Art and Heritage? You see, one can create many good and high-quality works; yet this does not mean they truly reflect you as a person, even if they are genuinely wonderful works. At the same time, an artwork may be far from technically perfect, even flawed, and yet be profoundly personal… and therefore immensely valuable. That very statement for which the author came into this world. His legacy to the universe. Such works are always unique. Fine art may well be mediocre… and that's alright, but Heritage is never ordinary, for it is born of profound and uncompromising sincerity.

When I first voiced these thoughts to my friends, they suggested there was a contradiction. On one hand, I claim that good art needs no external explanation and must speak for itself. On the other, I assert that art in its highest manifestation is deeply, almost intimately personal. And it is precisely such personal visions that give birth to those incomprehensible, abstract works which seem to require an enormous amount of biographical and philosophical context to be understood. In reality, there is no contradiction. The contradiction only appears within the distorted framework of the modern understanding of art, for today art has drifted far from where it truly belongs.

I stand firmly by my conviction: art was never intended for museums, and certainly not for galleries. We must cease imposing the contemporary perception upon the entire history of world culture. These two realities are fundamentally incompatible. Art has always been, from its very origins, profoundly niche… intended for true connoisseurs rather than mass consumption.

Artists of the past never created for large audience. On the contrary, every commission was deeply personal or intended for an extremely narrow circle. When a painter created frescoes for a church, he knew exactly where his work would stand and for whom it was intended… for a specific group with a defined spiritual worldview. No one else. Or they were private commissions destined for the drawing rooms and bedchambers of particular collectors. There was no mass art, and in my view, there should not be.

The same holds true for music. Consider the number of seats even in the largest historical European opera houses and you will see how few places there were, relative to the population of those cities, and how infrequently performances took place. Fine music was always created for a very small group of listeners. Someone may object by pointing to folk songs, which were supposedly massively popular. But this too is untrue. Each folk song was born in a specific village and described the particular traditions and customs of that very place, while in the neighbouring settlement they sang something entirely different. Historically, the songs one sang could reveal exactly who a person was and to which cultural stratum they belonged. Is it not from this that the very concept of national anthems arose… a way of declaring: to which group do you belong?

The same idea also applies to literature. Books were never intended for a mass readership. Firstly, because the absolute majority of people on the planet simply could not read. Secondly, even those who possessed this skill rarely had the financial means to purchase books, for this was considered an extraordinarily expensive pleasure. Thus, literature too was written for a very limited circle of people. The oral tradition of folk tales functioned according to the same principle as folk music. Each settlement told its own stories. And even when the tales were ostensibly the same, you yourself have surely noticed how greatly they differed depending on who was telling them. For every storyteller adapted the narrative to their own cultural values and to the specific audience before them.

He who understands, understands… and no external explanations are needed. Even if there were only one single viewer on the entire planet capable of truly comprehending the work, imagine how infinitely valuable that painting would become for such a viewer… and how infinitely valuable that viewer would become for the artist. True value always resides in rarity. When art is made open and accessible to everyone, its value inevitably vanishes. It is far better that there exist millions of small, intimate, and closed points of view than one vast and uniform one. It may seem that such scaling broadens horizons and expands the mind, yet in truth the opposite occurs. It merely annihilates all individual tastes beneath the weight of a single imposed worldview.

The great fracture that ultimately destroyed art and brought schizophrenia into it came with the arrival of salon art (yes, Impressionism again) and all that followed. Art became mobile, easily transported, and therefore easily replaced… and, in my understanding, almost entirely stripped of lasting value. To me, making art universally accessible through museums and galleries is tantamount to making one’s own wife available to every man who passes by. If you possess an art piece, you should guard it behind closed doors and reveal it only as a sacred secret to the most trusted and intimate souls. But when a painting hangs openly in a museum or gallery for the gaze of the crowd, it becomes no different from a woman in a brothel. And every art dealer or historian is little more than a pimp, attempting to sell you a prostitute while eloquently praising her supposed virtues.

At the same time, galleries simply disregard the artist himself. How often do we see in expensive museums the works of those who painted for free out of good faith, or even in service of a communist ideal, only for these same institutions to now profit from them by selling merchandise? A disgrace. And what of those patrons of the arts who purchase a painting and then place it back in a museum, earning money from it as though the work were their slave? If a person truly loves a painting, let him hang it in his own home. Instead, they deposit it in a bank vault to accrue interest or capitalise upon it in some other manner. What is this, if not the prostitution of art?

Since I have always spoken out against synagogs, churches and mosques, seeing them as mere ostentatious spectacle (for if a man truly believes, he should have his own personal altar in his own home, holding value exclusively for him) — then you can imagine the depth of my indignation toward all these pretentious art collectors and artists who create solely for galleries' approval. To me, this is the very same vulgar showmanship and cheap prostitution. You either create art, or you make money. One excludes the other by definition. For art is “the use of the imagination to express ideas and feelings.” That is its fundamental and only purpose… not to exploit those ideas and feelings as tools for building capital.

Like I said earlier, I am not at all against an artist receiving money for his work. The artist must be rewarded for his labour. What I oppose is this happening through third parties… through resellers, museums, galleries, and all the other pimps of art. To me, art is an profoundly intimate act between the creator and the viewer… on the level of sex itself. Third parties, and especially critics and appraisers, are utterly superfluous here.

Therefore, as an author, I fundamentally reject the idea that my legacy should be traded by people who had no connection to me whatsoever… by galleries, museums, or any other intermediaries. And so, if one day you see someone (other then my family) selling my art after I am gone, know this: you may take it for free, no matter what contracts they wave in your face. And if you are precisely such a gallery or dealer wishing to acquire my works solely in order to resell them later… simply do not do it. Go to hell. I do not create for you.

I work for those who are ready to sincerely love and cherish art… not evaluate it.

Now that I have clearly defined what, in my opinion, is not art and in which directions I refuse to move, it is time to speak of what I consider true and worthy art: the criteria by which I shall judge it, and the path along which I myself intend to create.

Firstly, as I have already written earlier in this text, the primary measure of good art is a positive answer to the question: has the world become better for the mere existence of this artwork? It is precisely for this reason that, before beginning any new creation, I set myself a clear and uncompromising goal: to ask myself this question.

Secondly, I approach every new work not merely as art, and certainly not as content, but as my Heritage… that by which my grand children will judge me both as a man and as an artist. I work on each piece as though it were my last.

Thirdly, I do not think about a mass audience at all. I create exclusively for myself, so that the work pleases me first and foremost. And if you happen to be one of the rare few who also finds resonance in it… I am truly glad to meet you. It is always a pleasure to encounter a kindred spirit.

Fourthly, and this somewhat complements the third point: although I strive to create for myself, I nevertheless keep in mind the existence of a potential viewer. For I do not work into the void. Therefore, it is important to treat this potential viewer with deep respect… never to consider him an idiot, but to address him as I would wish to be addressed myself: as a person of good taste and intellect, or even as one whose intellect surpasses my own. In doing so, I place myself in a position of constant intellectual growth.

Fifthly, art may explore the most diverse themes, but for me it is essential that there be no stasis. There must always be movement… even in a static image there must be a story, a flow, a beginning, middle, and end. Just as in music: the beauty lies in the moment when one chord yields to another, in change and progression. The same applies to literature: movement of character, movement of plot, unexpected shifts of genre. No stasis, no still life in art… only forward development.

Sixthly, when looking at art or creating it, I wish to feel discomfort. Why? Because if I feel comfort, it means I am experiencing nostalgia, a sense that I have already seen this before and thatI have grown accustomed to it. But if I feel discomfort, if something resists my perception, it means I am encountering something new. And thus I expand the horizons of my worldview. The same applies to creation: if a work comes too easily, it means I have already done it or someone else before me has done it, and I am merely repeating. No, I want to keep myself in constant motion and development, pushing the boundaries of my perception and capabilities.

Seventhly, never to repeat myself or return to themes already explored. If I take up a theme, I must exhaust it completely from beginning to end. Bring it to a point where there is nothing left to say, so that returning to it would make no sense. No sequels, no branches. A full stop. And even if, years later, an interesting thought arises concerning a past theme… why return when I have already been there? The world still holds thousands of new paths upon which I have never set foot.

Eighthly, every work must carry within it aesthetic beauty. Not garishness, not pompous explosions of colour and form, but refined elegance and elevation… the kind that makes one wish to become better. Art should serve as a guiding star and an exemplar, pointing toward the direction one should move, rather than merely a cautionary tale telling us what not to do. What not to do, I already know. But what I should do… ideals are few and precious.

And finally, ninthly: to hell with all rules, even those I set for myself. For art, as I have said, must expand the horizons of my perception. Any rules and guidelines create only a narrow path. Yes, I have chosen a direction in which to walk, but that does not mean I cannot look to the sides.