| A Common Grave of Fashion’s Victims |
At the turn of the millennium, when I was still an adolescent, there existed in the world something that has since all but vanished… I speak of countercultures.
I myself never belonged to any of them, though I was on the closest terms with goths, emos and other denizens of the alternative scenes, and even trailed after them to the occasional underground concert. Those around me, however, were firmly convinced that I formed part of the metal subculture… And although I never claimed the label for myself, I suspect they were right in every particular. My hair has always grown long of its own accord, I have always favoured loose black clothing, yet never once did metal appear upon my garments… for there was already metal enough upon my body. From childhood I walked with metal orthopaedic braces upon my legs… devices that allowed me to move at all. From beneath my trouser hems there always showed those heavy metal supports, weighing kilos. The metal on my person was present not because it was fashionable, but because it was necessary. Whether I liked it or not.
In truth, even in youth I disliked the manner in which people approached these countercultures. For there floated about such abstract notions as “true” and “fake”.
Mercifully, no one ever pressed such questions upon me… perhaps because metal heads are the least complicated of lads, always ready to help one another. Or perhaps simply because I never attempted to pass myself off as anything I was not.
Yet all around me I heard the constant carping: “You’re not a real goth. You’re a fake.” Or: “to be a true emo one must do this or that. And no matter what people did, they were still pronounced fakes.
I regarded it as pure spite… an attempt to find fault so that, by humiliating the weaker party, one might feel larger oneself. And yet, somewhere beneath the surface, I always understood that these people were not entirely wrong. Teenagers so often strained every sinew to prove they were not fake; and the harder they tried, the more thoroughly fake they became.
In order to demonstrate that he was a true emo, a boy would dress exactly like the idol of his favourite band, thereby seeking to prove to the world that he was an individual… without ever noticing the irony that he was merely a cheap copy of another human being. Or the punks who sought to convince society that they stood against fashion, yet every last one of them cropped the same mohawk or clothed themselves in the costly capitalist brand Vivienne Westwood, wearing the identical logo as everyone else, never grasping that Vivienne Westwood bags are sold both to punks and to the pink bimbo girls against whom those same punks try to define themselves.
The older I grew, the more I found myself agreeing with this division of people into “true” and “fakes”. For I began, quite swiftly, to observe that a great many people possess nothing of themselves beyond the label and the garments they pin upon their bodies. Consider: if a person loves the gothic subculture, then he is obliged to love the band Bauhaus, for they are held to be among the founders of the movement. And thus arise millions of adherents of one and the same counterculture who are, in reality, mere replicas of one another. They like precisely what the other followers like. No room remains for a private opinion. The irony, I think, is glaring. People struggle so desperately to prove they are not like everyone else… and in the process produce millions of identical beings who are “not like everyone else”.
From the vantage of the years I have lived, I look back upon those who were called fakes. And I can concede that that is exactly what they were. Perhaps other teenagers did treat them with excessive harshness in calling them so; yet one cannot but acknowledge that those adolescents simply sensed the counterfeit… people without any inner core… and, lacking any better words, named them accordingly. These were people who treated every subculture and every trend not as a way of life, not as a reflection of their own inner self, but as a costume for Hallowe’en or any other festival. If such-and-such was in fashion today, they wore it. If something else was in fashion tomorrow, they would wear that instead.
One is reminded of the recent (and thoroughly poor) series drawn from the Addams Family franchise, centred upon the girl Wednesday. Millions of young women across the globe declared that Wednesday was “so me”. Then the film about the pink doll Barbie appeared, and those same young women announced that this, too, was “so me”. Tomorrow some further major production will arrive, and the identical chorus will proclaim that it, likewise, is about them. Such is the entire depth of their personality.
I can even offer two personal stories in which I myself fell for this foolish snare. I remember how, after watching The Matrix, it seemed to me that I had learned to see through reality and had acquired some unique knowledge… At twelve I sincerely believed myself special. Later, however, I became administrator of a large internet forum devoted to fans of the film. And there I discovered that such enlightened fashion victims… clad in long black coats, wearing sunglasses at night and uttering pseudo-philosophical phrases numbered in the thousands. Each of them undertook to instruct me in the precise steps required to reach a more correct enlightenment, for mine, as they claimed, was insufficiently true.
The second story is still more revealing. When I went to study at a film school, one of my fellow students began to expound upon his deep admiration for the work of Tim Burton. Tim Burton, he declared, was a director only for true connoisseurs… those who make films not for the common run of people… “For misfits,” as he put it. And since he himself believed he was not like everyone else, Tim Burton had somehow managed to create films as though expressly for him, affirming his personal uniqueness. The irony, of course, was that every single person in that school agreed with him wholeheartedly, insisting that they shared the same view, and that yes… Tim Burton seemed to make films precisely for each of them. Every one was convinced that he alone was the unique misfit, and that his taste was therefore special simply because he liked Tim Burton. No dissenting voice was raised. And the most comic part was that, listening to all these identically unique individuals, I sat there thinking that I rather liked a good many of his films myself. Ouch. So much for my uniqueness and refined sensibility.
The capitalist machine long ago mastered the art of selling the sensation of uniqueness. It is not your special taste… it is merchandise pressed upon you the better to be sold, wrapped in the packaging of personal choice.
This became clear to me only after I moved to Paris, where my brother worked in the fashion industry. There I began to observe the grinding machinery from within. The cult of personality and the brand logo were treated as the very measures of taste and status. I watched millions of people dress themselves in the most absurd, strident clothing that suited them not at all. Yet because the garments bore the name of a celebrated designer, people felt they had no moral right to criticise the look.
I saw individuals dressed exactly like the worst Russian gopniks, yet because that same clothing carried the logo of an expensive house and belonged to the new collection, it ceased to be the cheap, disreputable gopnik style and became the very standard of elegance. The identical jumper without a logo is a disgrace — with a logo it is a mark of high standing… And anyone who knows even a little of the fashion trade knows that the clothes for the cheapest African street toughs and those for the most exclusive French boutiques are sewn in the same Chinese factories.
Thousands upon thousands believe that by putting on garments by a particular designer they become something more than they are. They imagine that a designer who has never seen them can, by the mere act of designing, somehow underline their uniqueness. I have never encountered a greater absurdity. Yet people sincerely believe it, and every day they enter fashionable shops to purchase yet another fashionable outfit, with the result that everyone on the planet now looks exactly like everyone else.
I see it thus: people have been offered a single uniform of slaves, which they gladly buy with their own money in the belief that they will thereby become masters.
The matter concerns not only appearance but scent. I hold that a person’s smell reveals far more about him than anything else. It is a natural instinct, natural pheromones, a unique code of the human being, comparable to fingerprints. Yet people buy designer perfumes and smell precisely like millions of others across the globe. And somehow each remains convinced of his uniqueness. Then they wonder why it is so difficult to find a companion prepared to love them as they are. The answer is plain… these people are not who they are. A throng of mediocre fakes. In this approach the naked emperor possesses far more sincerity and sense.
But the meat-grinder of capitalism does not stop there. It is the genuinely creative who suffer most, those who stand out from the crowd. The moment such a person appears, corporations seize upon him at once, appropriate his ideas and convert them into merchandise for a new brand. What yesterday was made from the heart becomes today a cold imitation.
It is as if Jesus died upon the cross that men might cease trading in the temples, only for those same temples, centuries later, to sell mass-produced images of him. Or consider the modern adoration of Frida Kahlo. I know a hundred people who worship her and will buy any article connected with her name, forgetting that she was a communist who devoted her life to fighting the very idea of capitalism and commerce. The final entries in her private diary speak of her longing to disappear and be forgotten. Yet years later she has been transformed into an immortal capitalist fashion trend. I know of no crueller horror story.
One is reminded of the internet jest known as Rule 34: any idea you can conceive already exists, and pornography has been made of it. The same holds true of culture. The instant something cultural and interesting appears, it is immediately vulgarised and sold. Nothing in this world remains sacred.
“So why even bother, if the world will grind you up in any case?” some fake may ask. And I answer that he is right… You need not bother. The more you bother, the less you are. You have only to be yourself, irrespective of what others think. For if you bother in order to prove something to the world, then you are already a fake.
If you attempt to invent an image and a style in a single day, or even a week, or even a year, it is already a counterfeit. Your mother required nine months merely to carry you in her womb. Do you truly imagine that individuality can be born with equal speed, at the snap of a finger? Everything needs time.
And if you are able to read these words, then you have already lived some portion of your life upon this planet and have formed certain habits that belong to you alone. Even if you dislike them… and especially if those around you dislike them… you must remember that it is precisely these habits and small particulars that make you who you truly are. These are the things that cannot be fabricated. Above all I urge you to notice what you do when no one is watching. For you do those things for yourself alone, and therefore they are the most sincere.
Here is a good… or rather a very bad… example. When I spoke with women about their make-up, they all declared with one voice that they applied it not to appear beautiful to others, but for themselves… Yet every time I video-called them or arrived unannounced at their homes in the middle of the day, they would ask me to wait while they changed and put on their make-up. To which I always posed the reasonable question: if you dress and paint yourselves first and foremost for your own sake, why do you not do so during ordinary domestic life when you are alone? The answer is obvious… it is performance.
And it is precisely here that one sees clearly who is genuine and who is fake. A genuine lady will walk about the house in a dress and heels, made-up, even while preparing dinner; she will not wait for some special occasion. A man who loves tailored jackets will wear them to the doctor and to the shops… he will not reserve them for an office meeting or an evening at the theatre. What is natural to a person remains natural.
The truth is that I always notice such details… whether someone puts a thing on once a year, or wears it as a matter of course.
It’s like sport. A person athletic by nature will find a bar at any convenient moment and exercise every day. He has no need of a special journey to the gym. And just as with sport, a sense of taste and of self can be cultivated through constancy and discipline. Do a thing often enough and it becomes habit… habit becomes part of one’s being.
Yet one must not forget that, although one ought to dress for oneself, a human being still lives in society. You may fashion any look you please, but that does not oblige society to accept you or to play by your rules. Behind closed doors you may appear as you wish, yet those around you have their own perceptions and their own codes, and you cannot impose yours upon them.
I have often met foolish girls who don the most sexualised stockings, high heels and mini-skirts in the name of self-expression, and then take offence when lecherous men approach them. Or people who dress like complete degenerates yet invest their appearance with some private meaning intelligible only to themselves, and expect that others will not treat them as degenerates.
The commonest case I encounter is that of people with tattoos. Modern folk acquire thoroughly tasteless and, from the standpoint of symbolism, stupid tattoos merely because they find them somehow attractive… and then wonder why I, who know something of the symbolism and history of tattoos, do not accord them the respect they appear to expect.
Someone will object that I contradict myself: should one not be indifferent to my opinion, since they do this for their own self-expression? And I answer that they are right. They are obliged to do everything for their own self-expression. But, as I have said, behind closed doors and under closed clothing they may do as they please. Those around them need not see their tattoos, scars, piercings or other private parts. If they choose to display them, then they must be prepared to accept criticism… or else refrain from displaying them at all.
For when such things are put on show, they remind me of those ostentatiously religious people who pray only when someone is watching. They will always wear the largest cross, light the most elaborately huge candle in full view of others, and every Sunday make a public spectacle of attending church and bowing lower than anyone else. Still more frequently I meet witches who perform their rituals in public, filming them daily for the internet: ‘“Look what a witch I am, what dark rites I enact.” All of it is pure display… pure fake. For if a person sincerely believes and performs rituals, he does so in silence, alone. These are the most intimate acts, on the level of sex. I will tell you a secret — I have never yet met a porn actress who truly climaxes on camera. And I met hundreds of them.
You see that we have touched upon the most varied subjects, yet the root of them all is one and the same. People live in the paradigm of “not to be, but to seem for others”. And so their own identity dies.
What, then, helps a person preserve his true individuality? I would say those things without which you find it hard to imagine yourself… things that have accompanied you throughout your life and without which you would no longer be yourself.
For my own part, I have had long hair all my life. Not because it was a fashion statement, but simply because it has always grown that way of its own nature. Have I cut it? Yes, and often. At times I was entirely bald. Yet every time it happened I looked in the mirror and could not recognise myself. I felt that the person looking back was no longer me. Could I survive without it? Of course I could. It must not become fanaticism, a form of dependence. But when I try to describe myself to myself, I see long hair.
It is the same with clothing. If a person has worn a certain kind of dress all his life, then when he puts on something different he already feels uncomfortable. Again I offer a personal example. From earliest childhood, because of those orthopaedic braces, it took only a couple of falls (inevitable given my weak health) for the metal to tear my clothes. My trousers were always full of holes. This was never a fashion statement but a natural consequence of circumstance. Did I like holey trousers? Probably not. Yet they were part of what made me who I was. And today, looking at new trousers without holes, I already feel that something is missing.
A similar thing occurred with the braces themselves and the specialised footwear made for them. It was always handmade, ordered to measure, fashioned for my particular foot. In recent years, however, I have ceased to wear those irons, for I now move about in a wheelchair and no longer require orthopaedic assistance. Consequently I began to wear ordinary shoes — very handsome, designer pieces, yet still quite ordinary. I confess that throughout childhood I detested that medical footwear. I considered it the ugliest design in the history of mankind. Yet now, years later, looking at old photographs, I see that those shoes were in fact truly unique. They were of a kind that no one else has ever possessed, or ever will.
Once, at a party, an acquaintance brought his new girlfriend and, apparently wishing to impress her, sat beside me and began to display every item of his wardrobe. “Jurii, look… this tie is Hermès, the jacket Dolce & Gabbana, the belt Dior, the trousers from some other fashionable house that all look alike to me…” He went on at length describing how elaborate and costly his attire was, while I listened in silence, looking him steadily in the eye. When at last he finished his futile monologue, I answered, still without blinking: “And my shoes are custom made.” In that instant he coloured with shame. Yes, they were not beautiful medical shoes, but they were unique and made for me alone. Hearing my reply, he even grew embarrassed and whispered: “Please don’t embarrass me any further in front of my girlfriend.” Idiot.
And, as it turned out, I truly missed that footwear. I returned to those craftsmen and ordered several new pairs. Only now, being adult and in control of the situation, I myself specified the design that would please me. Thus I remain faithful to myself, continue the tradition of a lifetime, and at the same time develop aesthetically. And so it is with every element of dress.
Many will say that not everyone has the financial means to dress beautifully. That is complete nonsense. Even on very little money one can dress with beauty and taste. Those who truly wish to will find a way. And secondly, people somehow forget that shops selling mass-produced clothing appeared only in the twentieth century. For the whole of the rest of human history people made their own clothes through tailors, or they made them themselves. But now, forsooth, they claim they need money and a trip to the shops simply in order to be clothed. And the truth is that to sew one’s own garment always proves, in financial terms, cheaper than going out to buy it.
My wife Alexandra is a master of sewing and design. She makes every piece of our clothing herself. We ignore fashion trends entirely and wear only what reflects our life and our mood. Each garment tells a story… our story. We never dress merely because it is convenient to seize whatever lies to hand in order to cover nakedness. Everything is chosen according to mood, so that it may tell a particular tale and introduce specific feelings into the world.
There is a saying that one is met according to one’s clothes and seen off according to one’s mind. It has always been taken to mean that appearance does not matter… only intellect counts. I believe, rather, that the one is a continuation of the other. An intelligent person will not permit himself to look badly. He will employ every surrounding detail in order to leave the fullest possible imprint of himself upon the story of this life.